Skip to main content

The Three Pillars of AI Arbitrage: A Framework for Higher Ed and Non-Profits

AI Arbitrage Week 2

By Rick Aman
on

“Colleges and universities are being asked to operate in a world for which they were not designed.” — Arthur Levine & Scott Van Pelt, The Great Upheaval (2021)

AI arbitrage is already reshaping higher education. In simple terms, arbitrage is the advantage gained when leaders act before others do. In the AI era, speed creates early benefit, but clarity, guardrails, and readiness determine whether that advantage lasts. Over the past year I’ve worked with boards, CEOs, and nonprofit leaders who all feel the same tension: we know AI is here, but we’re unclear about how to begin. My encouragement - Start where you can make real progress: establish clear expectations, reduce friction, and elevate teaching and learning. Those three priorities become the pillars of durable AI adoption.

This week, I want to offer a practical framework leaders can use immediately, one that I’ve already seen improve operations, strengthen academic quality, and reduce anxiety across teams. Whether you're leading a college, overseeing a nonprofit, or chairing a governing board, these three pillars create the structure needed to move from hesitation to confident action.

1. Policy and Ethics — Setting the Guardrails for Trustworthy Innovation

Every institution wants the benefits of AI, but very few want to learn those lessons the hard way. Policies are not meant to slow innovation; they create the confidence that allows innovation to flourish. In my consulting work, the most effective leaders establish clear expectations early. They aren’t writing long manuals; they give teams clarity on questions that matter: data handling, privacy, transparency, academic integrity, and comfort around experimentation.

When these guardrails are in place, people stop guessing. Staff feel safer trying new tools, students understand expectations, faculty have a consistent baseline, and boards gain confidence that the institution is moving responsibly.

Leverage - Institutions move faster when these elements are clear:

Outcome: A climate where innovation is supported, safe, and aligned with institutional purpose.

2. Operational Efficiencies — Reclaiming Time, Reducing Friction, and Improving Service

The first visible benefit of AI appears in operations. Every college and nonprofit has processes that drain time: email responses, scheduling, repetitive communication, routing documents, drafting HR language, preparing reports. These tasks consume hours  and AI can remove that friction immediately.

I’ve seen admissions teams streamline intake workflows, advising departments use AI-generated triage responses, IT help-desks cut ticket backlogs, and presidents use AI to summarize complex reports and environmental scans. All of these small efficiencies add up to significant regained capacity.

When teams spend less time on routine tasks, they have more time for service and problem-solving the work that actually strengthens student and community experience.

Leverage - Where early adopters see the fastest gains:

Outcome: Less friction, faster service, and more time for what matters - student success, staff support, and mission impact.

3. Teaching, Learning, and Employability — Preparing Students and Faculty for an AI-Enabled Future

“We need to prepare students for jobs that do not yet exist and technologies that have not yet been invented.” — Diana G. Oblinger, former President of EDUCAUSE, EDUCAUSE Review (2012)

The core of higher education always lies in teaching and learning. AI is not replacing the human role; it's changing what good teaching and learning look like. Faculty gain time. Students gain tools. Graduates gain employability advantage.

Colleges are beginning to use AI to accelerate curriculum development, support more personalized learning, and equip students with the skills employers now demand. This is the pillar where AI arbitrage becomes mission-aligned: faculty teach better, students learn faster, and graduates leave more prepared for the world they are entering.

For Faculty (Teaching) - AI improves instructional quality while freeing time for mentoring and engagement.

Outcome: Faculty spend more time teaching and less time drafting documents and managing repetitive tasks.

For Students (Learning) - AI supports mastery, not shortcuts. It offers personalized guidance, structured feedback, and accessible resources.

Outcome: Students gain deeper understanding, improved confidence, and stronger study habits.

For the Workforce (Employability) - Employers expect AI fluency. Colleges that teach responsible use give their graduates a measurable advantage.

Outcome: Graduates become trusted, capable contributors, a competitive edge for both students and the institution.

Pulling the Three Pillars Together

When these three pillars work in concert; clear policy, streamlined operations, and strengthened academic quality the institution begins to move differently. Staff feel supported. Faculty gain time for teaching. Students see better learning environments. Boards become more confident. And CEOs can lead with clarity instead of reacting to uncertainty.

AI arbitrage is not a high-tech strategy reserved for large universities. Community colleges, nonprofits, and mission-driven organizations can move quickly and responsibly. The advantage belongs to leaders who start early, learn openly, and align innovation with purpose.

Closing Reflection

Across my leadership roles, I’ve learned that institutions don’t thrive because they avoid change. They thrive because they face change with clarity and alignment. AI is no exception. Begin with guardrails. Reduce friction. Strengthen teaching and learning. Do these things well, and the institution gains momentum that compounds over time.

----

If your board or leadership team is ready to explore practical steps toward AI readiness, I’d welcome a conversation. At Aman and Associates, I help organizations use AI-assisted futuring to create clarity, alignment, and purpose. Whether you’re beginning adoption, identifying opportunities, or shaping a preferred future, I’m ready to support that work.

I also offer a half-day digital executive retreat for boards and senior leadership teams who want to understand AI arbitrage, reduce uncertainty, and align around early, practical steps. Feel free to DM me for ideas.

Rick Aman, PhD

Aman and Associates - rick@rickaman.com | rickaman.com/articles