Category: The Second Outcome

  • The Second Outcome: Writing – Week 3

    The Second Outcome: Writing – Week 3

    When AI Helps Us Write, What Happens to the Writer?

    “Writing is thinking. To write well is to think clearly. That’s why it’s so hard.” — David McCullough

    Artificial intelligence has changed the way we write remarkably quickly. It can draft an email, summarize a report, critique an article, prepare a proposal, or polish a speech in seconds. For boards, CEOs, executive teams, and educators, the productivity implications are significant. The First Outcome is easy to see: better writing, produced faster.

    But writing has never been only about producing words. Writing is also part of how we think. In developing an argument, searching for the right words, reconsidering a paragraph, or trying to explain a complex idea, we are doing more than creating a document. We are developing clarity, reasoning, judgment, and creativity. The writing is one outcome; what happens to the writer is another.

    AI changes that relationship because it can now perform more of the work that once belonged exclusively to us. That does not make AI good or bad for writing. It creates a new question about how much of the work should remain human and how much should be delegated to AI.

    That is the question I want to explore in this third article on the Second Outcome: When AI helps us write, what happens to the writer?

    Writing Has Always Produced Two Outcomes

    Writing produces a product, but at the same time it produces a Second Outcome. Through writing, we develop critical thinking, reasoning, creativity, personal voice, and the ability to organize complex ideas. The document matters. But so does the development of the person who created it.

    As I have thought about writing and the Second Outcome, I have begun to picture our use of AI on a continuum. At one end is all human; at the other is all AI. Between those endpoints are different combinations of human and artificial intelligence: human creation, human-led work with AI assistance, genuine human–AI collaboration, AI-led work with human review, and eventually work produced almost entirely by AI.

    ALL HUMAN ←────────────────────────────→ ALL AI

    The goal is not to find the midpoint of this continuum and declare it the proper balance. Different kinds of work should occur at different places on the continuum. If I have a 50-page report that I need summarized before a meeting, I may intentionally move toward the AI end. There is little developmental value in spending two hours manually summarizing information that AI can accurately organize in two minutes. Those two hours can be used for something requiring judgment, conversation, or leadership.

    But suppose the task is developing an argument about the future direction of an organization, preparing remarks intended to persuade people to think differently, working through a difficult board recommendation, or trying to understand an issue that is not yet resolved. An educator might be asking a student to construct an argument for the first time. In these situations, where we operate on the continuum matters differently because the process itself has value. That creates two very different questions. For the First Outcome, we might ask where on the continuum we can produce the best document. For the Second Outcome, we need to ask where on the continuum we develop the best thinker and writer.

    The AI Paradox

    This is what I think of as the AI paradox. AI can improve the First Outcome, the product, while potentially diminishing the Second, the human skill developed in producing it. The concern is not that AI writes poorly. The more interesting challenge is that AI can write remarkably well when prompted well and thoughtfully vetted. If the writing were obviously bad, we would simply reject it. Instead, AI increasingly gives us something that looks finished. It is organized, grammatically correct, persuasive, and sometimes even sounds like us. That makes it tempting to move directly from prompt to polished product.

    But think for a moment about what may have disappeared between the prompt and the product. Traditionally, much of the intellectual development associated with writing happened in that space. We wrestled with competing ideas, determined what mattered, discovered weaknesses in our arguments, made choices, and occasionally changed our minds. What looked like inefficiency was often where the thinking occurred. The struggle was not necessarily a flaw in the process; sometimes the struggle was the process. This has obvious implications for education. A beautifully written student paper no longer necessarily tells us how much the student learned in producing it. But this is not simply an educational issue. The same applies to executives preparing recommendations, CEOs developing strategy, and board members considering difficult issues. A sophisticated document does not necessarily reveal how much intellectual work occurred in producing it. That matters because organizations are not simply producing documents. They are also developing people. If AI helps us produce increasingly impressive work while the underlying human capacity for reasoning, judgment, creativity, and communication begins to decline, we may not recognize the trade until much later.

    The question, then, is not whether we should use AI to write. We already are, and its capabilities will only become more powerful. The more useful question is how we use it without unnecessarily surrendering the human development that has traditionally occurred through writing.

    Finding the Right Place on the Writing Continuum

    One way to think about that choice is to consider the process we use when writing with AI. The simplest model is to give AI a prompt and accept the resulting product. That may be perfectly appropriate for some routine tasks. But when the quality of our thinking matters as much as the efficiency of the output, a different model may better protect both outcomes:

    Human Insight → AI Dialogue → Human Judgment → Refined Product

    In this model, the human begins with the insight or question. AI helps challenge, organize, critique, and refine the thinking. The human then exercises judgment about what is useful, what is missing, what should be rejected, and ultimately what the final product should say. Used this way, AI becomes a thinking partner rather than a substitute thinker.

    For organizational leaders, this distinction will become increasingly important. We will all be making decisions, formally or informally, about where work should occur on the Human–AI Continuum. We should not assume that everything should move toward AI simply because it can. Some work absolutely should. If AI can remove routine writing, summarize information, improve grammar, organize background material, or reduce hours spent on low-value tasks, we should take advantage of those capabilities.

    Other activities, however, may need to remain intentionally more human because the process itself develops capabilities we value. A student learning to reason, an emerging leader learning to articulate a position, an executive wrestling with strategy, or a governing board considering the future of an organization may gain something important from the uniquely human intellectual work involved. Efficiency is still valuable, but it is not the only outcome that matters.

    Leaders therefore need to ask more than whether AI improved the document. We should also ask whether the process improved the thinker. That question has long-term implications for an organization. If AI continuously improves our immediate outputs while gradually weakening human critical thinking, we may achieve extraordinary productivity today while diminishing capabilities we will need tomorrow. On the other hand, if we learn to use AI in ways that challenge our thinking, expand our perspective, and improve our judgment, the Second Outcome could be as powerful as the First.

    The important leadership decision, then, may not be whether to use AI. It may be determining where on the continuum we want AI to operate for a particular activity and why. That choice should reflect not only the product we want to create, but also the human capability we want to preserve or develop.

    The Second Outcome Test

    This is not an argument for resisting AI or protecting old ways of working simply because they are familiar. The opportunity is to decide intentionally how much of a particular activity should belong to the human and how much should belong to AI. Sometimes we primarily need the product. Sometimes the development of the person matters more. Most of the time, we need both.

    Writing gives us a useful place to begin because the effects are already visible. AI is becoming an extraordinary writing partner, and it can make us more efficient and effective communicators. But the Second Outcome is not automatic. It depends on where we choose to place ourselves on the Human–AI Continuum and what part of the intellectual work we choose to retain.

    So, the next time you use AI to prepare a board recommendation, article, strategic plan, or important email, consider where you are operating on that continuum. Ask whether AI helped you produce a better document. Then ask the Second Outcome question: After using AI to write this, am I a better thinker and writer—or simply the owner of a better document?

     —-

    The challenge is not whether we will use AI, but whether we will use it in ways that strengthen both what we produce and who we become.

    If your governing board or executive team is exploring this challenge, I facilitate a two-hour retreat focused on AI, leadership, and the human capabilities organizations must preserve for their preferred future.

    Rick Aman, PhD, Aman & Associates

    rick@rickaman.com | rickaman.com

     

  • The Second Outcome – Week 2

    The Second Outcome – Week 2

    Every Meaningful Activity Produces Two Outcomes

    “The greatest question in the age of AI is no longer simply, ‘What did we produce?’ It is also, ‘Who did we become while producing it?’”

    Artificial intelligence is transforming the way we work. It is helping us write, research, summarize, and solve problems with remarkable speed and increasing sophistication. Every month new capabilities emerge, and AI is becoming part of everyday leadership. Most conversations about AI naturally focus on results. We ask whether the report is better, whether the analysis is more accurate, whether productivity has improved, or whether decisions can be made more efficiently. Those are important questions because organizations exist to accomplish meaningful work, and better tools should help us produce better outcomes. At the same time, higher education is wrestling with a different concern. Its mission has never been simply to produce assignments, but to develop students who can think critically, reason effectively, communicate clearly, and solve complex problems. As AI becomes increasingly capable of performing many of those tasks, educators are asking an important question: How do we preserve the learning process that develops those uniquely human capabilities? Although business organizations and educational institutions approach AI from different perspectives, they are beginning to confront the same leadership challenge. How do we embrace AI’s extraordinary ability to improve what we produce while ensuring it also strengthens who we become? That simple observation became the foundation for what I call The Second Outcome.

    Every Meaningful Activity Produces Two Outcomes

    Every meaningful activity changes two things. It changes the work we produce, and it changes us in the process of producing it. The visible result is the one we naturally celebrate. It is the completed report, the strategic plan, the presentation, the budget, or the lesson. Organizations measure these outcomes because they are tangible. They can be evaluated, improved, and reported, becoming the milestones by which progress is measured. But another outcome is unfolding at the same time.

    Every project shapes the people who complete it. Every difficult decision develops judgment. Every strategic planning process strengthens or weakens the team’s ability to think together. Every challenge requires us to learn something new. The work leaves its mark not only on the organization but also on the people doing the work.

    That second outcome is easy to overlook because it is not immediately visible. It appears gradually in the form of wisdom, discernment, confidence, resilience, creativity, and leadership. It is reflected in the person who has become more capable because of the work they have done. The first outcome is what we produce. The second outcome is who we become while producing it.

    The Two Outcomes Have Always Been Connected

    For most of history, these two outcomes developed together. A physician became a better physician by caring for patients. A teacher became a better teacher through years in the classroom. A craftsman refined skill through practice. A leader developed judgment by making difficult decisions, learning from mistakes, and carrying responsibility over time.

    The work itself became the classroom. The process developed capabilities that could not be acquired by observation alone. Experience produced more than results. It developed wisdom, confidence, and discernment. It formed habits of thought and patterns of leadership that became part of the individual. Looking back, we often remember the accomplishments. We celebrate the bridge that was built, the organization that was transformed, or the strategy that succeeded. Yet those visible accomplishments tell only part of the story. Hidden within every achievement is another story, the story of the people who grew through the process of creating it.

    Perhaps this is why meaningful work has always been about more than completing tasks. It has always been one of the primary ways human beings learn, mature, and prepare themselves for greater responsibility. The work changes the world around us. The process changes the person within us. For generations, these two outcomes have been inseparable.

    Artificial Intelligence Changes the Relationship

    Artificial intelligence introduces something new. For the first time, many of the activities that once developed human capability can now be performed, at least in part, by a remarkably capable partner. AI can generate a first draft, organize information, summarize research, propose solutions, and even assist with strategic thinking.

    This is not something to fear. I believe organizations should embrace these capabilities. They will improve productivity, expand creativity, and help leaders focus their attention on higher-value work.

    Yet AI also presents a leadership challenge we have not faced before. If technology increasingly produces the visible outcome, who is intentionally developing the invisible one?

    If AI writes the first draft, how do we ensure the writer continues developing?

    If AI performs much of the analysis, how do we continue strengthening judgment?

    If AI accelerates decision support, how do leaders continue developing discernment?

    The issue is not whether AI can perform these tasks. Increasingly, it can. The question is whether our use of AI continues strengthening the human capabilities that effective leadership has always required. Technology has always changed the way we work. Artificial intelligence may be the first technology that also requires us to think intentionally about how the work continues to shape the worker.

    The New Responsibility of Leadership

    This is where the framework becomes a leadership responsibility. Boards, CEOs, executive teams, and educators have always been responsible for more than producing results. they have been responsible for developing people. That responsibility has become even more important in the age of AI. While organizations will continue to measure productivity, quality, and performance, leaders must also ask whether their people are becoming better thinkers, exercising stronger judgment, and growing in wisdom and discernment. Organizations that thrive will not simply be those that use AI most effectively, but those that simultaneously and intentionally develop the uniquely human qualities that technology cannot replace. That is the second outcome; the enduring human capacity developed while accomplishing the work.

    Summary

    Every meaningful activity produces two outcomes. One is the visible work we accomplish; the other is the person or organization we become through accomplishing it. The first outcome determines today’s results. The second outcome shapes tomorrow’s workforce. As artificial intelligence continues transforming how we work, I believe leaders must become just as intentional about developing people as they are about improving productivity.

    Over the coming weeks, we’ll explore how this framework applies to the everyday work of leadership. We’ll begin with one of the most familiar activities of all – writing. AI can help us produce a document with remarkable speed and quality, but only the human being becomes the writer. That distinction, I believe, offers our first practical glimpse into the power of the Second Outcome. Because in the end, leadership will never be measured solely by what we produce. It will also be measured by who we become while producing it.

    —–

    If these ideas resonate with your organization, let’s continue the conversation. I facilitate executive leadership and governing board retreats (as short as two hours) that help organizations move beyond AI tools and toward AI-ready leadership.

    Rick Aman, PhD Aman & Associates – rick@rickaman.com | rickaman.com

  • The Second Outcome – What AI Produces. What Humans Become.

    The Second Outcome – What AI Produces. What Humans Become.

    What AI Produces. What Humans Become.

    “The greatest question in the age of AI is no longer simply, ‘What did we produce?’ It is also, ‘Who did we become while producing it?’” — Rick Aman

    A Prelude

    Artificial intelligence is transforming leadership faster than most organizations can adapt. Every week brings new capabilities, new opportunities, and new questions. Governing boards, CEOs, educators, and community leaders are all wrestling with the same challenge: How do we harness AI while continuing to lead wisely?

    Over the past year, my writing has explored this challenge through three leadership frameworks. Ikigai for Organizations asked, Why do we exist? The Preferred Future explored, Where are we going? The Wisdom Triad examined, How do we make wise decisions?

    Artificial intelligence has shifted much of our attention toward production. AI can research, write, analyze, summarize, and generate ideas in seconds. Those capabilities are remarkable, and organizations that ignore them risk falling behind. Yet beneath these advances lies a growing leadership tension. Higher education is asking whether AI may reduce opportunities to develop research, critical thinking, writing, and communication. At the same time, organizations are embracing AI to increase productivity, redesign knowledge work, and improve efficiency. Both perspectives are understandable. One emphasizes developing human capability; the other emphasizes maximizing organizational performance.

    This series begins with a different question. What if every meaningful use of AI produces two outcomes? The first outcome is the work we produce. The second outcome is the person, leader, learner, or organization we become while producing it. AI will continue transforming what we produce. The more enduring leadership challenge may be ensuring it also strengthens who we become.

    Leadership Begins with Better Questions

    Over the past year, I’ve had the privilege of exploring these ideas through a series of LinkedIn articles and conversations with governing boards, CEOs, educators, and community leaders. Looking back, I now realize those conversations were leading me somewhere I didn’t fully anticipate. Looking back, I can see that each framework began with a single leadership question.

    The first explored Organizational WHY, drawing on the principles of Ikigai for Organizations. Every organization needs a clear center—a shared understanding of its purpose, mission, values, and identity. Without that center, strategy becomes fragmented, priorities compete with one another, and decision-making loses coherence. Before leaders can decide what to do, they must first understand Why the organization exists.

    That naturally led to the next question. Purpose without direction is incomplete. Organizations do not drift toward excellence. They intentionally choose the future they want to create. My series on the Preferred Future examined how leaders define a compelling destination, align strategic priorities, and build organizations capable of creating tomorrow rather than merely reacting to it. The question shifted from purpose to direction: Where are we going?

    As artificial intelligence rapidly expanded its capabilities, another leadership challenge emerged. Information was becoming abundant, analysis increasingly instantaneous, and answers easier to obtain. Yet leadership has never been about information alone. AI can discover patterns, but leaders must still determine what those patterns mean and how they should influence action. That realization led to the Wisdom Triad, a framework and an AI prompting methodology for moving from Revelation to Instruction to Application. The question became: How do we make wise decisions?

    Although each framework addressed a different aspect of leadership, they all shared a common purpose: helping organizations think more clearly about the future.

    A Question I Didn’t Expect

    As I continued writing, facilitating strategic planning sessions, and working with governing boards and executive teams, another question began to emerge.

    It wasn’t a question about organizational purpose.

    It wasn’t a about strategic direction.

    It wasn’t even about decision-making.

    It was a question about human development.

    Artificial intelligence is becoming remarkably effective at helping us produce work. It assists with writing, research, analysis, planning, and problem-solving. Each advance promises greater speed, greater efficiency, and better results. Those are worthwhile outcomes, and organizations should absolutely learn how to leverage them.

    But I found myself wondering whether we were paying equal attention to something else. While AI increasingly helps us produce better work, what is it producing in us?

    How is it shaping the way we think?

    How is it influencing our judgment?

    Is it affecting the development of future leaders?

    Is it changing the capabilities of the organizations we serve?

    These are not questions about technology. They are questions about leadership. And they are questions I believe deserve far more attention than they have received.

    Looking Ahead

    That realization became the foundation for my next leadership framework. I believe it begins with what may be the most personal leadership question I have explored. Like the frameworks that preceded it, it starts with a question. Yet this question reaches beyond purpose, strategy, governance, and decision-making. It asks us to consider not only the results we achieve, but also the people and organizations we are becoming in the process.

    I call this new framework The Second Outcome. This framework grew naturally out of the conversations we’ve shared over the past year. Ikigai for Organizations raised the question, Why do we exist? The Preferred Future investigated, Where are we going? The Wisdom Triad assessed, How do we make wise decisions?

    An Invitation

    Every generation of leaders faces defining questions. Some emerge gradually. Others arrive almost overnight. I believe artificial intelligence has introduced one of those defining moments.

    Over the coming weeks, we’ll explore that moment through familiar leadership domains; writing, learning, leadership, governance, and our evolving partnership with artificial intelligence. AI is an extraordinary tool, and I believe organizations should embrace its potential. My concern is not whether AI will transform our work, but whether we will continue developing the wisdom, judgment, and character needed to lead well while using it. Those qualities have never been more valuable than they are today.

    If you’ve followed my writing over the past year, thank you for joining me on this journey. Together we’ve explored purpose, direction, and wise decision-making. If you’re new to these conversations, I hope you’ll take time to explore those earlier frameworks. Each stands on its own, but together they provide the foundation for this next conversation. Purpose. Direction. Wisdom.

    And now, perhaps the defining leadership question of the AI era: Who are we becoming?

    —-

    If your governing board or executive leadership team is exploring how artificial intelligence will influence strategy, governance, and leadership, this conversation deserves more than a meeting agenda item.

    At Aman & Associates, I facilitate a two-hour executive leadership or governing board retreat designed to help organizations move beyond AI tools and toward AI-ready leadership. Together, we examine emerging opportunities, governance implications, strategic questions, and the uniquely human capabilities organizations must continue developing in the age of artificial intelligence.

    Because the future will not be shaped only by what AI produces. It will also be shaped by who we become while using it.

    Rick Aman, PhD – Aman & Associates – rick@rickaman.com | rickaman.com