Author: Rick Aman

  • The Year Intelligence Gets Cheap

    The Year Intelligence Gets Cheap

    The cost to use a given level of AI falls about 10x every 12 months, and lower prices lead to much more use. Moore’s law changed the world at 2x every 18 months; this is unbelievably stronger. — Sam Altman, “Three Observations,” February 2025

    What a Thought Used to Cost

    Let me put the AI cost concept into plain terms, because the whole argument of this week hides inside it. AI sells intelligence by the token, a fragment of a word. A million tokens is about 750,000 words, roughly five long novels in length, reasoned through, with questions answered. Price that cost per unit honestly, and you can watch the ground move under every organization in this series.

    As the founding president of College of Eastern Idaho, analysis of this level was a budget line, and a serious one. A program demand study cost five figures and took a semester, and by the time the report landed, the labor market it described had already shifted. Consultants billed by the day. Boards rationed their questions because answers were expensive, and presidents guessed more than any of us admitted at the time.

    This week I asked a machine for the first draft of an environmental scan of eastern Idaho aimed at a community college demographic, and it arrived before my coffee cooled and it cost less than the coffee.

    This concept of declining costs of compute is the second force of the Last Normal Year, and it is the one leaders feel last, because it arrives dressed as good news. Intelligence is getting cheap. Clarity is not. Everything still ahead in this series, the delegation of work, the drawing of lines, the premium on judgment, runs on this curve. So let us look at the curve itself.

    The Collapse of Compute, in Three Numbers

    First number. Stanford’s AI Index, the most careful annual count of this field, tracked the cost of querying a model at the performance level of the systems everyone met in late 2022. In November 2022, that work cost $20.00 per million tokens. By October 2024, it cost $0.07. The price of a fixed unit of machine intelligence fell more than 280 times in twenty-three months.

    Hold that against the computing curve our generation planned by. Moore’s law doubled computing power about every eighteen months, and it rebuilt the modern world at that pace. To fall 280-fold at Moore’s pace would have taken roughly twelve years. This took less than two.

    Second number. Epoch AI, which tracks the cheapest way to buy a fixed level of capability, found prices falling between 9 and 900 times per year depending on the task, with a median near 50 times per year. Performance at the level of GPT-4, the breakthrough system of 2023, fell from $37.50 per million tokens to $0.18 between March 2023 and February 2025. Read that as a board member. A capability that three years ago only the best-funded labs and companies could afford to use at scale now rents for pennies. Other trackers, the venture firm Andreessen Horowitz among them, put the sustained rate at roughly ten times cheaper per year for the same capability. So far, Altman’s 10x rule has been the conservative estimate, not the aggressive one.

    The third number may matter most because it helps explain the first two. In 2022, achieving a score above 60 percent on a widely used AI knowledge and reasoning test required an enormous AI model with 540 billion parameters, the internal values a model uses to process information and generate answers. The test, known as MMLU (Massive Multitask Language Understanding), measures how well AI answers questions across dozens of subjects, from history and science to mathematics and law. At the time, a model of that size required the computing power of a data center.

    By 2024, a model of 3.8 billion parameters cleared the same bar. Intelligence is not only getting cheaper. It is getting smaller, which means it is getting local: onto the laptop, the phone, and soon the device on the student’s desk and the trustee’s kitchen table, no procurement process required and no permission asked.

    Translate the seven cents into institutional terms. At that price, a college could have a machine read its entire catalog, every syllabus it offers, and ten years of board minutes, then summarize all of it, for less than what one hour of a consultant’s time used to cost. The constraint on institutional self-knowledge is no longer the money. It is whether anyone thinks to ask, and whether anyone checks what comes back.

    Every era gets one input whose price collapses: steam, electricity, computing, cellular airtime. Each time, the institutions that won were not simply the ones that bought the input. They were the ones that redesigned around it. Add these three numbers together and the conclusion is not merely that AI became affordable. It is that the economics beneath every knowledge institution have inverted. The scarce input around which, for a century, we built our budgets, our hierarchies, and an entire consulting industry is on its way to free.

    What Scarcity Becomes

    When a resource gets cheap, the value does not vanish. It moves. For a hundred years, our institutions were organized, reasonably, around the scarcity of analysis. Staff offices, research shops, and consulting firms existed because thinking at scale was expensive, and the executive’s craft was deciding which few questions deserved the cost.

    The rationing is now obsolete. The craft is not; it has been promoted. When answers are abundant and nearly free, the bottleneck of leadership moves upstream, to three things that are not getting cheaper. The first is the question. Peter Drucker warned that the important and difficult job is never to find the right answers; it is to find the right question. In a world of seven-cent answers, the quality of leadership increasingly depends on the quality of inquiry.

    The second is verification. Cheap answers arrive fluent, confident, and occasionally wrong, and they arrive by the thousand. Someone has to check them against the record, and checking well is slow, disciplined human work. The third is judgment: deciding what the answers mean for this institution, these students, this mission. AI can make an answer cheap. It cannot make the Why cheap, and the Why still belongs to the board. And notice: none of the three, question, verification, or judgment, can be delegated without losing the thing itself. A board that outsources its questions has outsourced its leadership; however cheap the answers get.

    There is a budgeting trap inside the good news, and boards with collaboration of CEOs should name it before their CFOs do. When the price of a unit falls, total use explodes. Economists call it Jevons paradox. Enterprise spending on LLM services rose from $3.5 billion to $8.4 billion in six months during 2025, even as the unit price was collapsing. Do not budget for savings from cheap intelligence. Budget for reallocation, because every department will find ten new uses for a resource that costs seven cents, and they will be right about most of them.

    One caution, because clarity includes honesty about the curve itself. Epoch AI notes that the fastest price declines may not persist, and the frontier of capability keeps getting more expensive even as yesterday’s frontier gets cheap. Institutions will live on both curves at once. Knowing which curve a given decision stands on is part of the new clarity.

    Three Questions for the Boardroom

    So put three questions on the agenda, in the boardroom and in the cabinet meeting alike.

    First question. If analysis costs nothing, what work do we stop doing? Every institution carries reports nobody reads and studies commissioned to postpone a decision. Cheap intelligence exposes them, because neither defense holds anymore: the reports were excused by the cost of thinking, and the studies by the safety of delay.

    Second question. Where are we still rationing thought out of habit? Policies, approval chains, and planning cycles built in the age of expensive answers now ration a resource that costs seven cents. Some of that rationing still protects the mission. Much of it is simply the past, governing the present.

    Third question. Which of our past decisions were really purchases of scarce expertise, and what are they worth now? Contracts, positions, and partnerships bought for access to analysis deserve a fresh look, not because they were wrong, but because the scarcity they answered is ending.

    The governing question of this series still sits above all three: does this move us toward our Preferred Future? The institutions that thrive after normal will not be the ones with the most intelligence. Intelligence is about to be free, and free things differentiate no one. They will be the institutions whose leaders stayed clear: clear about purpose, clear about their questions, and clear about the decisions that remain stubbornly, valuably human.

    Next week: what happens when change arrives in every sector at the same time.

    At Aman and Associates, we work with governing boards, CEOs, and executive teams to strengthen organizational focus and align resources with mission and impact. In a focused two-hour Zoom Futuring Session for your board or executive team, we help leaders step beyond traditional planning to define their Preferred Future and examine what should continue, what should change, and what may have completed its useful life.

    Rick Aman, PhD | Aman and Associates

    rick@rickaman.com | rickaman.com/articles

  • The Year AI Stopped Answering Questions and Starts Working

    The Year AI Stopped Answering Questions and Starts Working

    Just as electricity transformed almost everything 100 years ago, today I actually have a hard time thinking of an industry that I don’t think AI will transform in the next several years. — Andrew Ng, Stanford, 2017

    As I begin the first of five themes that will make up my thesis of this series, let me state the concept plainly. 2026 is the last year artificial intelligence will be thought of as a parlor trick, a clever novelty for the early adopters down the hall. In 2027, adoption begins in earnest, and not gradually. Once a capability crosses from interesting to indispensable, organizations move all at once, and the adoption curve turns vertical.

    If 2026 is the last normal year, it is worth pausing to say what normal actually looked like. It looked stable. Artificial intelligence was in our institutions, but it lived on the fringe, in the hands of early adopters, used mostly for research. We asked it things. Which restaurants near the theater take reservations? When is the finance committee free? What do these invoices say? Then we took the answer and did the work ourselves; made the call, chased the calendars, matched the paperwork by hand. From the executive team or board table, all of that looked manageable, a policy here, a pilot there. It was a reasonable response to the technology as it then stood. The trouble is that the technology is not standing still.

    2027 is where the migration begins. The early adopters, as they usually do, are showing us the destination first: the move from research to task accomplishment, from asking AI to assigning it. “Book a table for four, Friday at seven, Italian near the theater,” and the table is held, the confirmation sent, the calendar marked. “Get the finance committee together next week for ninety minutes,” and five calendars are checked, a room booked, invitations sent, the packet assembled. “Match this month’s invoices against our contracts and pay what agrees,” and the routine is paid and filed while only the exceptions wait for a human. Notice what changed. The deliverable is no longer an answer. It is an outcome. And once AI can be handed outcomes, a new question moves to the center of institutional life: which tasks should it be assigned, and which should it never touch? That is not a technology question. It is a leadership or governance question, and it belongs to boards or CEOs.

    Let me own the nuance before going further. AI has not stopped answering questions, and it will go on answering them. What has shifted is the center of gravity. I know the difference from my own practice. For years I have taught leaders to prompt with a role, with information, and with a mission, and to make the machine interview them before it advises them. That was still a conversation, a better one, but a conversation. What is arriving now is that same discipline put into action: a task handed over with an outcome attached, and the work done while you do something else. An answer sits there waiting for you. An agent acts.

    The Evidence Is Already Here

    This is not a forecast. Anthropic, the company behind Claude, tracks how its systems are actually used in its Economic Index, and its September 2025 report found that in business use through its API, the programming doorway through which a company’s own software assigns work to AI directly, 77 percent of the use was automation: work delegated, not questions discussed. The honest caveat: those customers are early adopters, technology-forward firms who wired AI in first, and 77 percent is not your college or your nonprofit today. But early adopters are not an exception to the future. They are its preview. What they are doing with software now, institutions will do with operations next, because the tools are being built for delegation and priced for everyone. None of that is happening at scale in colleges and nonprofits yet, and the timeline matters for this series; in our institutions, 2026 is still the year of questions, and assigned work arrives in 2027.

    Look for the early signs in work every leader will recognize. Advising outreach that assembles itself. Invoices processed end to end except for the exceptions. Vendor contracts gathered and cross-checked before legal reads them. Donor research compiled overnight. Board packets assembled from five sources into one. Environmental scanning that used to wait for a consultant’s visit. None of this requires imagining a new institution. It requires noticing that assigned work, quietly, has begun.

    What Changes Inside the Institution

    Workflows change before job descriptions do. That sequence is worth the leadership attention, because it means the transformation will be well underway before it appears in any organizational chart or personnel policy. A process gets quietly rewired. Then another. Only later does anyone rewrite the job that used to contain those steps.

    What moves first is the repetitive, the multi-step, and the rules-based: the work with clear inputs, clear steps, and a checkable outcome. In a college or a nonprofit, that is a larger share of the operating budget than most leadership teams realize, spread across finance, human resources, facilities, and reporting. What remains for people is the work at either end of the process: setting the task well, and reviewing what comes back. Staff time shifts from producing first drafts and chasing routine steps toward verifying, correcting, and judging machine output.

    That shift sounds simple and is not. Reviewing well is a higher skill than producing routinely, and it is a different skill. The employee who once learned the institution by doing its paperwork now meets the institution through exceptions and judgments. Presidents should expect a training and supervision question here long before they face a staffing question, and boards should expect to hear about it in those terms.

    Delegation Is a Leadership Act

    Here is the governance core. The most important decision leaders make about AI is not what it can do, but what it must never decide.

    Boards and executives already know how to delegate. Boards delegate to presidents, to committees, to auditors; CEOs delegate to cabinets and staff; in every case with authority limits, approval thresholds, and reporting lines, and they review the results. Delegating to an agent requires the same discipline, set just as deliberately; what it may do alone, what requires a human signature, and what is off limits entirely. The clean rule is this. AI proposes. Humans choose. AI executes.

    The discipline has two levels, and they follow the institution’s own logic. The boundary around purpose belongs to the board alone; why this institution exists and what it stands for is the board’s to hold. Inside that boundary, the working rules of delegation are set by the CEO and the leadership team, under limits the board approves. What makes both levels necessary is a property of the machine itself. Ask AI a factual question and it answers. Ask it for options and scenarios, the What of strategy, and it answers, and that is legitimate work for it. Ask it a Why question, why this institution exists, what we stand for, whether we should do this at all, and it will answer that too, fluently, confidently, and with no marker anywhere that a boundary has been crossed. Nothing in the machine distinguishes the question it should answer from the question it must never be asked to settle. If those boundaries are not marked by the humans charged with them, they will not exist.

    One more refinement, because it closes a loophole. It is tempting to say leadership keeps the Why and the What and simply delegates the How. But when AI produces three execution paths, complete with costs, timelines, and a confident recommendation, and the institution takes the recommended one, a decision has been made, about money, risk, people, and sometimes mission. Where there are multiple Hows, choosing among them is deciding. Humans must do the choosing, openly, and then let the machine execute what was chosen. Delegation that hides a decision inside a recommendation is not delegation. It is abdication with better formatting.

    Wrong at Machine Speed

    The risks of the agent era are specific, and they begin with scale. A wrong answer sits in one place, where one person can catch it. A wrong agent, acting at machine speed inside connected systems, can be wrong in a hundred places before anyone notices. The error is no longer an event. It is a pattern, filed, sent, and paid.

    The defense is not suspicion, and it is not slowness. It is the discipline of verification, applied before trust. In my own work I use a simple three-part check I call the Wisdom Triad. Revelation: what are we actually seeing, in the output and in the record of what the agent did? Instruction: what does it mean for us? Application: what should we do next? With a six-step sanity check underneath it: verify the facts, examine the sources, challenge the assumptions, look for what is missing, seek an alternative view, and apply human judgment. Note the order. Human judgment is the final step of the process, not its first casualty.

    One deeper question I will raise here and deliberately not resolve. If agents do the doing, what happens to the people who used to learn by doing it? Judgment is trained on routine work long before it is exercised on hard cases. That is Week 6 ground, when we take up the premium that cheap answers place on human judgment, and it is planted here because boards and leadership teams should start watching for it now.

    So, begin Monday morning with one question on the agenda, in the boardroom and in the cabinet meeting alike: “What work in this institution is ready to hand to an agent, and what work must we never hand over?” Ask it in that order, and do not let the meeting leave with only the first half answered. Then set the answer where this series began, under the governing question of Week 1: “Does this move us toward our Preferred Future?” The institutions that thrive in the years after normal will not be the ones that delegated the most. They will be the ones that delegated deliberately, and kept the deciding for themselves.

    Next week: what happens when intelligence itself gets cheap.

    —–

    At Aman and Associates, we work with governing boards, CEOs, and executive teams to strengthen organizational focus and align resources with mission and impact. Through board retreats, strategic conversations, or a focused two-hour Zoom Futuring session, we help leaders step beyond traditional planning to define their Preferred Future and examine what should continue, what should change, and what may have completed its useful life.

    Rick Aman, PhD | Aman and Associates

    rick@rickaman.com | rickaman.com/articles

  • The Last Normal Year – When AI Ends Normal

    The Last Normal Year – When AI Ends Normal

    When AI Ends Normal

    “The best way to predict the future is to invent it.” — Alan Kay

    Two months ago I stood in an innovation and technology building in Idaho Falls and watched a ribbon cut. The Future Tech Building is the kind of facility a community dreams about for a generation. What stayed with me was not the building. It was the timeline. The voters who approved a new community college in our region in 2017 could not have described the technology that this building now houses. They were never asked to. They were asked to choose a direction, and the future filled in the details.

    Institutions are always living inside decisions made years earlier. The only real question is whether the next set of decisions gets made as deliberately as that one was.

    A Phrase Worth Borrowing

    James Mullarney of InvestAnswers, in a recent conversation with Jo Bhakdi, called 2026 “the last normal year.” I have borrowed his phrase for this series because it names something I have been watching from boardrooms and accreditation visits across the Northwest: the foundations under our institutions are beginning to move at a different pace.

    Let me be clear about what I am claiming and what I am not. I am not predicting. Prediction is a claim about what will happen, and honest people should loosely hold such claims. I am interpreting. There is a difference. A pilot does not predict the weather over the North Pacific; they interpret it, respect it, and plan the route accordingly. Leaders owe their boards the same discipline with emerging technology: not prophecy, but careful reading of what is already in motion.

    What I am seeing is this. In 2026, a governing board can still treat artificial intelligence as a side experiment, a trial in one department, a line item that can wait for next year’s budget. Beginning in earnest in 2027, AI becomes an operating condition of the institution. We will begin to assume it in budgets, staffing plans, advising, programming, and the questions employers and reviewers ask of us. The AI experimental phase is ending, whether we believe in it or not, and whether we scheduled its end or not.

    Over the next six weeks I will take what I believe to be five AI themes, one at a time, and interpret them for the future of nonprofit organizations. The five are these: 1. AI that stops answering questions and starts doing work, 2. intelligence that gets cheap, 3. change that arrives in every organizational sector at once, 4. the leadership and governance question of where the line between human and machine gets drawn, and 5. the premium that cheap answers place on human judgment. But first, boards and leaders need to understand the shape of the change itself, because the shape is what makes this moment different.

    The S-Curves Are Colliding

    Every technology follows an S-curve: a slow, flat beginning where change is easy to dismiss, a steep middle where improvement compounds quickly, and a plateau of maturity. The telephone took some seventy-five years to run that arc; the smartphone ran it in about a decade. Most of us who lead institutions built our instincts on the flat parts of those curves, where next year reliably resembled last year, with minor adjustments. Psychologists call the habit normalcy bias, the assumption that tomorrow will be like yesterday. It served us well on the flat parts. It misleads us on the bend.

    Artificial intelligence is not riding one S-curve. It is riding several at once. Capability is still climbing the steep middle of its curve. Cost is falling just as steeply down its own: Stanford’s 2025 AI Index reports that the cost of a given level of AI performance fell more than 280-fold between November 2022 and October 2024. Adoption is now entering its steep middle as these tools move from experiment to infrastructure. When S-curves collide, their effects do not add. They compound.

    This is why the plateau of the old curve is the most dangerous place an institution can stand. On the plateau, enrollments look stable, budgets balance, and the strategic plan appears to be working. Everything in the board packet says normal. But the plateau of one curve is often just the flat bottom of the next one viewed from above, and institutions that mistake a plateau for permanence are usually the last to know the bend has already happened beneath them.

    We have watched this movie before, at a slower speed. I spent part of my career in colleges that treated the internet as a side experiment: a computer lab here, a cautious online course there, a website maintained by whoever had time. Within a decade it was an operating condition. Registration, instruction, library services, advising, and the expectations of every student who walked in the door all assumed it. The colleges that read that curve early did not merely adopt technology sooner. They redesigned themselves while redesign was still cheap, and they set the terms their slower peers later had to meet. The difference this time is compression. That transition took the better part of fifteen years. The one now beginning will not grant us fifteen.

    Winner Takes Most

    The steep middle of an adoption curve rewards early adopters in a way the flat parts never did. Capability attracts talent, talent attracts resources, resources buy more capability. The technology world calls this dynamic winner takes most, and it is visible everywhere in the current build-out of computing power, data centers, and energy.

    Colleges and nonprofits sometimes assume this dynamic belongs to someone else’s sector. It does not. Students choose. Donors choose. Employers choose. The institution that learns fastest begins to set the expectations every other institution is measured against, in responsiveness, in personalization, in cost. Winner takes most does not mean one college or one organization takes everything. It means the rewards concentrate; the distinctive and the efficient pull away, applications and gifts and talent flow disproportionately toward them, and the comfortable middle, neither the least expensive nor the most distinctive, gets squeezed first. I do not offer that as a threat. I offer it as a planning fact. Capabilities built during the steep part of the curve are worth considerably more than the same capabilities built after the new plateau has reset everyone’s expectations, because by then they are no longer an advantage. They are merely the price of staying open.

    More Than AI Is Moving

    It would be a mistake, though, to plan for AI alone, because AI is not the only force in motion. The demographics of college-going are shifting, with fewer traditional-age students in many of the regions we serve. Public funding and public trust are both under pressure. Workforce expectations are being rewritten in real time. Planning for AI alone is planning too narrowly, because these forces do not arrive one at a time. Cheap intelligence is landing on institutions already strained by demography and economics, and the interaction of the forces matters more than any one of them in isolation.

    The Question Changes

    So the board’s question has to change. “What will happen to us?” is a spectator’s question, and boards were not seated to spectate. The governing question of the next several years is “What future will we choose?”

    That is not a slogan. It is the actual work. A Preferred Future is chosen deliberately or it is inherited by default; there is no third option in which the future politely waits for our planning cycle. The discipline I have used with boards for years still holds, and it matters more now: direction provides continuity while strategy provides adaptability. Mission stays steady. Plans flex. And one question belongs on every agenda, asked of every significant proposal that crosses the board table: Does this move us toward our Preferred Future?

    Ask it of the small things as well as the large ones. A contract renewal, a new position, a program that has run the same way for a decade: each either carries the institution toward the future it says it wants or spends its scarcest resources, time and attention, on the future it is leaving. Leaders that ask the question consistently, in season and out, will find that it quietly reorganizes everything else on the agenda.

    2026 is the last normal year. What we choose in it will be anything but normal in its consequences. Over the coming weeks we will look at each development in turn, and at what governing boards, presidents, and executive teams should do about them while choosing is still ours to do.

    Communities don’t drift toward greatness. They choose it.

    —–

    At Aman and Associates, we work with governing boards, CEOs, and executive teams to strengthen organizational focus and align resources with mission and impact. Through board retreats, strategic conversations, or a focused two-hour Zoom Futuring session, we help leaders step beyond traditional planning to define their Preferred Future and examine what should continue, what should change, and what may have completed its useful life.

     

    Rick Aman, PhD | Aman and Associates

    rick@rickaman.com | rickaman.com/articles

     

  • Less, But Better – What Deserves the Capacity we Created?

    Less, But Better – What Deserves the Capacity we Created?

    “If you don’t prioritize your life, someone else will.” — Greg McKeown, Essentialism

    For the past five weeks, I have been making a case that may sound counterintuitive: organizations rarely suffer from doing too little. They suffer from doing too much of what no longer matters. Throughout this series, we have followed a progression built around six leadership disciplines:

    Recognize → Evaluate → Simplify → Stop → Automate → Reinvest

    We began by recognizing how organizations accumulate work. We examined good programs that had outlived their usefulness, considered the hidden cost of organizational clutter, and argued that stopping should become a regular part of strategy rather than an act reserved for crisis. Last week, we explored how AI can automate necessary work that should never have consumed so much human time. Each step had the same underlying purpose: creating capacity for what matters most.

    Capacity can be created in two ways: by ending low-value work and by reducing the human effort that necessary work requires. But here is what I have learned from watching organizations do this well, and from watching them do it poorly: creating capacity was never the goal. It was only a means.

    The harder leadership question is the one this series has been building toward since the first week: What deserves the capacity we have just created? I have come to believe it is the question that separates organizations that merely got lighter from organizations that actually got better.

    The Capacity Trap

    Freed capacity does not stay free for long. Nature abhors a vacuum, and so does an inbox. When organizations eliminate a committee, simplify a process, or automate a report, the hours recovered do not sit quietly in reserve waiting for a strategic decision. They are quickly claimed by the next urgent request, the loudest voice, or another project competing for attention. Within a single quarter, an organization can undo much of the disciplined, courageous work it took to stop, simplify, and automate. The workload returns, often without anyone consciously deciding to take on more. Capacity that is not intentionally reinvested will almost certainly be consumed by default, a few unexamined hours at a time. Capacity that is not deliberately assigned will be accidentally spent.

    And accidental spending almost always favors the urgent over the important, the familiar over the future. If the board and the CEO do not establish what the freed time, talent, and funding are for, someone else will, usually whoever asks first.

    Three Claims on the Capacity You Created

    I see three competing claims for every hour and dollar an organization frees. Understanding these claims is essential because each has merit, but not all contribute equally to the organization’s Preferred Future.

    The first claim is the backlog. Every organization carries deferred work, including postponed projects, outdated systems, and worthwhile initiatives that never received sufficient attention or resources. Some of these deserve renewed consideration, but others represent activities that may no longer serve the organization’s mission or strategic direction. Before committing newly available capacity, leaders should evaluate these requests with the same discipline they would apply to any new initiative. A project does not become more important simply because it has been waiting longer.

    The second claim is your people. Leaders sometimes overlook the opportunity to reinvest capacity in the very people who helped create it. Not every hour saved needs to produce another hour of output. Professional development, time for thoughtful decision-making, and relief from constantly expanding workloads can strengthen both organizational performance and employee commitment. Investing in people is not a diversion from the Preferred Future; it is often one of the most important ways to achieve it.

    The third claim is your Preferred Future. This is the future your organization has intentionally chosen to create, typically three to five years ahead, and the destination toward which its strategy should be directed. Newly created capacity provides an opportunity to accelerate progress by strengthening essential capabilities, advancing strategic priorities, and developing partnerships and programs that move the organization forward. Yet these investments are often crowded out by immediate operational demands because the future seldom arrives with the urgency of today’s problems. Leaders must therefore make deliberate choices about where their limited resources will create the greatest long-term value.

    When we were transforming the College of Eastern Idaho from a technical college into a comprehensive community college, our trustees and leadership team regularly returned to a simple but powerful question: Does this activity move us toward creating a new and functioning community college? That question became a discipline for protecting leadership attention, institutional energy, and financial resources from activities that might be worthwhile but were not essential to the future we were building. The same discipline applies to the capacity organizations create today. The objective is not simply to find more time or accomplish more work, but to ensure that the capacity we recover is invested in what matters most.

    The Test: What Actually Deserves It?

    How does a leadership team decide? I suggest running every claim through three questions before a single hour is reassigned.

    1. Does this demonstrably advance our mission? Not in the loose sense that almost anything can be connected to the mission, but with outcomes we can describe and defend.

    2. Does this move us toward our planned Future? Will this investment strengthen the capabilities and priorities required to create the future we have chosen?

    3. Does this strengthen who we are? Does it reinforce the identity at the center of the organization, or merely add activity at its edges?

    Then make the decision visible. Throughout this series, I have recommended keeping a Capacity Ledger: what was stopped, what capacity was released, and where that capacity was reinvested. The ledger matters most here, at the end, because it converts good intentions into an accountable leadership decision. A governing board should be able to see the reinvestment, not simply applaud the subtraction.

    Finally, give the work a deadline. Within 90 days of creating capacity, leadership should be able to demonstrate three things: what we stopped, what capacity we created, and where we reinvested it. If you cannot show the third item, you did not finish the work of the first two.

    But reinvestment alone is not success. Within six to twelve months, leadership should be able to demonstrate whether that reinvestment produced meaningful progress toward the Preferred Future. Did we strengthen an important capability? Improve an outcome? Increase our effectiveness? Create greater value for the people and communities we serve?

    The distinction matters. Reallocating resources is an action. Demonstrating that those resources made a difference is an outcome. Boards have a particular responsibility in this final step. Management will feel the pull of the backlog and the urgency of the week. The board’s responsibility is to keep the Preferred Future in the room. That does not mean the board should direct operational decisions about how every hour or dollar is reassigned. Those decisions belong to the CEO and leadership team. The board establishes strategic expectations, ensures alignment with the organization’s Preferred Future, and monitors whether the reinvestment is producing meaningful results.

    “At least annually, the board should ask the questions this series ends with: (1) Show us what we stopped. (2) Show us the capacity it created. (3) Show us where it went. Then, (4) show us what difference it made.”

    An organization that can answer those questions has turned subtraction into strategy. One that cannot has only tidied up.

    Invested by Design

    That is the central message of Less, But Better. The goal was never simply to do less, but to create capacity for what matters most — and to do it better. Along the way we traced how organizations accumulate work, and how evaluating it honestly, simplifying what remains, stopping what no longer serves the mission, and automating what is necessary releases time, talent, and resources. But released capacity is only potential. The journey is complete only when that capacity is deliberately reinvested in the people, priorities, and capabilities that shape an organization’s Preferred Future.

    Less, But Better is not measured by activities eliminated or hours saved, but by progress toward the future we have chosen to create. Every organization will spend the capacity it releases, the only question is whether we will spend it by default or invest it by design.

    At Aman and Associates, I work with governing boards, CEOs, and executive teams to strengthen organizational focus and align resources with mission and impact. Through board retreats, strategic conversations, and a focused two-hour Zoom Futuring session, I help leaders step beyond traditional planning to define their Preferred Future and examine what should continue, what should change, and what may have completed its useful life.

    Rick Aman, PhD | Aman and Associates

    rick@rickaman.com | rickaman.com/articles

     

  • Less but Better; Stopping Should Become Part of Strategy

    Less but Better; Stopping Should Become Part of Strategy

    “The antidote [to a chaotic world] is the disciplined pursuit of less.” — Greg McKeown

    By Week 4, I planned for this series to move from diagnosis into disciplined action. In the earlier articles, I focused on why organizations accumulate work, how good programs can outlive their usefulness, and how organizational clutter consumes capacity. This week, I want to move from recognizing the problem to doing something about it.

    In my experience, most planning conversations are built around addition. We ask what new initiative should be launched, what service should be expanded, or what new opportunity should be pursued. Those are reasonable questions, but they are only half of the strategic conversation. Far less often do we ask what should end. That imbalance matters. Organizations do not usually become overextended because of one bad decision. They become overextended through years of reasonable additions with very little subtraction. Each new activity may have made sense when it began. A committee solved a problem. A program met an emerging need. A new meeting improved coordination. But when those activities remain in place indefinitely, they begin to accumulate.

    Over time, the organization begins to carry more weight. The strategic plan expands. Employees are asked to support more initiatives. Leaders spend more time coordinating activity and less time thinking strategically. Eventually, capacity becomes stretched, not because people are unwilling to work, but because the organization has not been disciplined about deciding what no longer deserves attention.

    Stopping should become a normal part of board retreats, executive planning, budgeting, and strategic conversations rather than being reserved for moments of crisis or financial distress. Healthy organizations should routinely ask not only what they want to begin, but what they are willing to end. That is not negative thinking; it is stewardship.

    The Hidden Weight of Recurring Work

    When leaders think about stopping, they often focus first on programs. Programs are visible and tangible. They have budgets, staff, outcomes, and constituencies. But much of the clutter inside organizations is less obvious. It lives in recurring work that has gradually become permanent.

    During my years as a college senior leadership, I saw how easily routine activities became institutionalized. A report might be created for one board discussion and then continue for years. A committee might be formed around a temporary challenge and slowly become part of the organizational structure. A weekly meeting may have been useful during a particular transition but remain on the calendar long after the need has passed. None of these activities may appear especially burdensome by themselves, and that is what makes them difficult to evaluate. Collectively, however, they consume significant organizational capacity. A one-hour meeting involving ten people is not one hour of organizational time. It is ten hours before preparation and follow-up are even considered. A report that takes several employees two days to produce every month may represent hundreds of hours over a year. A committee that meets simply because it always has may be consuming attention that could be directed toward something more important.

    This is where leaders need to broaden the definition of organizational clutter. It is not only about underperforming programs. It is also about the accumulation of meetings, reports, approval processes, committees, dashboards, and practices that continue without being tested for current value. The challenge is that recurring work becomes almost invisible. People stop seeing it as a choice, and it simply becomes part of the operating environment.

    That is why one of the most useful strategic exercises is to imagine that nothing is automatically renewed. If a report had to justify its existence again, would we still produce it? If a meeting were not already on the calendar, would we schedule it today? If a committee did not exist, would we create it now?

    When we ask those questions, the burden shifts. Instead of asking why something should stop, we begin asking why it should continue.

    Creating Permission to Question What We Do

    One of the greatest obstacles to stopping low-value work is culture rather than process. Employees often know which activities create little value. They know which meetings repeat the same conversations, which reports are rarely used, and which processes create unnecessary friction. But knowing is not the same as feeling permission to say so.

    Sometimes a process was created by a former president. Sometimes a report is important to one influential person. Sometimes a committee has strong internal ownership. Over time, history becomes justification enough for continuation. I have learned that leaders play an important role in changing that dynamic. If we want people to identify work that is outdated, duplicative, or low-value, we must make it safe to raise the question. Employees should be able to challenge an activity without appearing to challenge the person who created it. The conversation should not be about blame; it should be about value. That brings me to the guiding question for this week: What could we stop doing tomorrow with little or no harm to the mission? I like this question because it immediately changes the tone. It does not ask what we dislike. It asks what we could remove without damaging what matters most. From there, I encourage leadership teams to look carefully at the ordinary work of the organization. Which meetings would no one miss? Which committees have outlived the issue that created them? Where are two departments doing essentially the same work? Stopping does not always mean eliminating something entirely. Sometimes the better answer is to combine, simplify, reduce frequency, automate, or delegate. The point is not to create a list of cuts. The point is to reduce unnecessary friction and recover capacity.

    This is also where leaders need to remain disciplined. Activity is not the same as impact. A full calendar can create the appearance of productivity while actually limiting the organization’s ability to do its most important work well.

    Stopping Creates Strategic Space

    Stopping is not the destination; it is a way to create room for something more important. If an organization eliminates several meetings but simply fills those hours with different meetings, nothing has been gained. If a report is discontinued but staff are immediately assigned another low-value task, the organization has not created capacity. It has only rearranged activity. The real value of stopping comes when leaders deliberately reclaim time and attention and redirect them toward higher-value work. That may mean giving employees more time to work directly with students or clients. It may mean allowing an executive team to focus on one strategic priority rather than five competing initiatives. It may mean using financial savings to strengthen an emerging program that clearly advances the organizational mission. It may simply mean creating enough margin in the organization for people to think, improve, and lead more effectively.

    I return often to the idea that clarity precedes progress. Organizations sometimes assume they need more resources when the first question should be whether they are using existing capacity intentionally. That is why stopping can be such an important leadership discipline. It creates space for better choices. The strongest organizations are not necessarily those doing the most. They are often the ones that are clearest about what matters and disciplined enough to protect the capacity required to do it well.

    This week, I encourage boards, CEOs, and executive teams to ask one practical question: What could we stop doing tomorrow with little or no harm to the mission? The answer may not be dramatic. It may be a meeting, a report, a committee, a process, or a practice that has simply outlived its value. But small decisions to stop can accumulate just as easily as small decisions to add. The difference is that subtraction creates room.

    —

    I work with governing boards, CEOs, and executive teams to strengthen organizational focus and align resources with mission and impact. Through board retreats, CEO mentoring, strategic conversations, and a focused two-hour Zoom Futuring session, I help leaders step beyond traditional planning to define their preferred future and examine what should continue, what should change, and what may have completed its useful life. Clarity about what belongs in the future, and what does not, is one of the most important forms of stewardship a leadership team can provide.

    Rick Aman, PhD, Aman & Associates – rick@rickaman.com | rickaman.com 

     

     

  • Less but Better: Using AI to Automate Repetitive Tasks

    Less but Better: Using AI to Automate Repetitive Tasks

    Using AI to Automate Repetitive Tasks

    “The first rule of any technology used in a business is that automation applied to an efficient operation will magnify the efficiency. The second is that automation applied to an inefficient operation will magnify the inefficiency.” — Bill Gates

    Last week, I wrote about the courage to stop, why stopping should become a regular part of strategy, not something reserved for crisis. There is a fair question that needs to be asked: what about the work that shouldn’t stop? The recurring work that genuinely matters, but quietly consumes our people’s days?

    It is the right question, and it points to a third option most organizations miss. We tend to treat work as binary: keep it or kill it. But some work still needs to be done; it just no longer needs to consume as much human time as it has in the past. I have watched enormous capacity disappear into recurring administrative work, meeting summaries, routine correspondence, reports prepared and prepared again. None of it was waste. But almost none of it was the best use of talented people’s judgment.

    That is why this article comes fifth in the series, not first. We spent four weeks making the argument to stop what shouldn’t exist because if you automate the clutter, you only magnify the confusion. Now, in an age of emerging AI, we can turn to what should remain, and ask: What work still needs to be done, but no longer needs to consume as much human time?

    Where AI Can Create Capacity

    When I talk with boards and executive teams about AI, I encourage them to start where the risk is lowest and the repetition is highest. Not with strategy. Not with judgment. With friction.

    The best candidates for automation share three traits: they are repetitive, they are rules-based, and they are time-consuming. Meeting summaries, routine correspondence, first drafts of recurring communications, program review. Anyone who has ever prepared accreditation evidence knows this pain. The recurring communications that keep an institution running but rarely change its direction.

    Higher education and nonprofits are full of massive-input work: large volumes of information that must be gathered, organized, and distilled before any human can usefully think about it: enrollment data, survey results, employer feedback. AI has immense ability here: not to decide what the data means, but to do the heavy lifting so human judgment can get to work faster. The value of AI in this role is not that it is impressive. It is that it removes friction. Every hour your people spend reformatting a report is an hour they are not spending with students, building partnerships, or thinking strategically. Automation should reduce organizational drag so that human energy flows toward the work that requires judgment, relationships, creativity, and mission knowledge, the work only people can do.

    Automate the Task – Not the Responsibility

    Here is where leadership must draw a bright line. AI can draft, organize, summarize, compare, and analyze. Accountability, however, remains entirely human. Automate the task, never the responsibility.

    I learned this distinction in a cockpit. Flying large search and rescue aircraft, the crew divided tasks and automation lived mostly in the autopilot, the navigation systems, and the warning systems. That division was deliberate: it kept the crew’s full attention on what could not be automated, the judgment calls, the weather decisions, the situational moments when lives depended on human discernment. The autopilot flew the routine. It never made the decision.

    Boards should think the same way. There are domains where human review is not optional; personnel decisions. Sensitive student or client matters. Governance judgments. Legal and financial decisions. High-stakes communications. In these areas, AI may inform the work, but it must never own the outcome.

    I frame it this way for the boards I advise: the Why is a purely human domain, purpose, values, identity. We should never ask AI our Why questions. But AI has immense abilities with the What and the How, and wise boards will depend on it there, for the repetitive, the mundane, and the massive-input tasks where summarizing and finding themes is the work itself.

    The governing principle is simple: the more consequential the decision, the more important the human role becomes. And a companion test, drawn from my LinkedIn Second Outcome writing; after using AI to produce this, are we better thinkers or simply the owners of a better document? If automation is quietly diminishing your people’s judgment, you have automated the wrong thing.

    From Saved Time to Better Work

    Which brings us to the point of the entire series. Automation only creates value if the capacity it frees is intentionally reinvested. Saved time is not the victory. Better-directed time is.

    Here is the trap I have watched organizations fall into: they automate successfully, reclaim hundreds of hours, and let those hours dissolve back into clutter. Nature abhors a vacuum, and so does an inbox. Without deliberate direction, reclaimed capacity fills with new low-value work, and the organization ends up where it started, only faster.

    I ask boards and CEOs a direct question; if repetitive work consumed less of your people’s days, what would you have them do more of? Spend time with students and clients. Think deeply about strategy instead of merely reacting to it. Build relationships with employers, donors, civic partners that no algorithm can build. Invest in professional development. Innovate. Improve service.

    One practical discipline: keep a capacity ledger. For everything you automate, record what was automated, the capacity it released, and where that capacity was reinvested. What gets measured gets directed, and what gets directed compounds.

    That sets up our final week. Across five articles, we have stopped what shouldn’t exist and automated what should remain but need never have been manual. Capacity has been created in two ways; by ending low-value work and by reducing the human effort necessary work requires. Next week, we close the series with the question all of this has been building toward: What deserves the capacity we have just created?

    —

    If your board or executive team is ready to move from carrying weight to creating room to stop what no longer serves, automate what should remain, and reinvest the capacity in what matters most, Aman and Associates is ready to partner with you. We design futuring retreats and leadership sessions that help organizations find their focus and build their preferred future.

    Rick Aman, PhD – Aman and Associates

    rick@rickaman.com | rickaman.com/articles

     

     

  • Less, but Better – The Cost of Organizational Clutter

    Less, but Better – The Cost of Organizational Clutter

    “There is nothing so useless as doing efficiently that which should not be done at all.” — Peter Drucker

    One of the easiest things for an organization to do is to add something. A new initiative is launched, a committee is formed, or a priority is added to the strategic plan. Usually, each decision makes sense at the time. Someone identifies a need or an opportunity, and the organization responds. The problem is that organizations are generally much better at adding than subtracting.

    Over time, that accumulation begins to matter. Programs, strategic initiatives, and expectations all compete for the same finite resources. Eventually, an organization can reach the point where its commitments exceed its practical capacity to execute them well. That is what I think of as organizational clutter.

    Last week, I wrote about the difficult distinction between a good program and the right program for the future. This week, I want to broaden that conversation. The issue is not simply whether an individual program or activity has value. The larger question is what happens when too many worthwhile things compete for the same organizational capacity. My guiding question for this week is: What is consuming capacity without producing enough mission value? Less, but Better LinkedIn Series.

    The Four Costs of Organizational Clutter

    During my years as a college president, I rarely encountered a shortage of good ideas. In fact, the opposite was usually true. There were always more worthwhile things we could do than we had the capacity to do well. The harder leadership task was determining which ideas deserved our limited resources and, just as importantly, recognizing when existing commitments were consuming resources that might be more valuable somewhere else. Organizational clutter rarely results from one obviously bad decision. It usually accumulates through many reasonable decisions made over time. Collectively, however, they consume four resources that every organization has in limited supply: time, money, employee capacity, and leadership attention.

    Time may be the easiest to underestimate. A two-hour meeting involving ten people is not really a two-hour commitment; it represents twenty hours of organizational capacity. Money is easier to see, but even there I think leaders sometimes ask whether something fits within the budget rather than whether it remains the best use of those dollars. Employee capacity is harder to quantify. People can absorb only so many priorities, initiatives, and additional responsibilities before their attention becomes fragmented and execution begins to suffer.

    Leadership attention may be the least visible cost of all. I have come to believe that the focused attention of a CEO and executive team is one of an organization’s most valuable resources. Leaders have limited capacity to think deeply about the future while simultaneously managing dozens of priorities and recurring demands. Every hour spent maintaining something of marginal value is an hour unavailable for something potentially more important.

    That is why I see organizational clutter as more than an efficiency problem. It is a stewardship issue. Every organizational commitment consumes capacity, and capacity committed in one place is unavailable somewhere else.

    When Everything Is Important

    I have reviewed many strategic plans containing ten, fifteen, or even twenty priorities. They are often filled with worthwhile ideas, but at some point they stop being priorities and become lists. A priority, by definition, requires choice. This is one of the reasons I prefer organizations to identify a relatively small number of key priorities. When leadership tells employees that everything is important, people are left to determine for themselves what actually deserves their attention. Resources spread across too many objectives, accountability becomes less clear, and execution becomes uneven. The organization may be very busy while making surprisingly little progress on the things that matter most.

    Strategic plans can unintentionally contribute to this problem. Instead of forcing choices, the planning process sometimes becomes a way to accommodate everyone’s interests. Another objective is added because a department believes its work needs to be represented. Another initiative is included because a constituency considers it important. Eventually, the plan describes almost everything the organization does rather than identifying the few things it must do particularly well.

    Boards and CEOs have an important responsibility here. Leadership is not simply about determining what else an organization should pursue. It is also about protecting the organization from pursuing too much. I think one of the more useful questions a governing board can periodically ask management is not, “What else should we be doing?” but rather, “Are we trying to do too much?”

    If everything is important, nothing is truly prioritized. Focus requires choices, and choices inevitably mean that some worthwhile projects will receive less attention so that the most important priorities can receive more. That is the central idea behind this Less, but Better LinkedIn series.

    The Real Cost Is Opportunity Cost

    The four costs of clutter are significant, but I believe there is an even more important cost: opportunity cost. It is relatively easy to calculate what a program, meeting, or initiative costs. It is much harder to see what the organization is unable to do because those resources are already committed.

    That changes the leadership conversation. Instead of simply asking, “What does this activity cost us?” I would ask, “What are we unable to accomplish because we continue doing it?”

    A program producing modest results may still be a good program, but what if those same resources could produce substantially greater mission impact somewhere else? A recurring management meeting may be useful, but what if reducing its frequency created meaningful time for leaders to work on a critical strategic initiative? A long-standing report may provide useful information, but what if technology now allows the same information to be produced with a fraction of the employee time?

    This is why I do not view organizational focus primarily as cost cutting. The objective is not simply to spend less or do less. The objective is to create capacity for what matters more.

    I think that distinction is important. Cost cutting begins with the question, “Where can we save?” Strategic subtraction begins with a different question: “Where could these resources create greater mission value?” That moves the discussion away from defending individual activities and toward comparing the relative value of competing uses of organizational capacity.

    Capacity Is a Strategic Asset

    Perhaps we should think about organizational capacity much as we think about financial resources. We would not knowingly leave substantial financial resources invested indefinitely without periodically examining the return. Yet organizations routinely allow time, money, employee energy, and leadership attention to remain committed without asking whether the value being produced still justifies the investment.

    I would encourage boards and executive teams to periodically examine major commitments through four questions: Does this still meaningfully advance our mission? Can we demonstrate meaningful outcomes or value? Is the capacity being consumed proportional to the value being produced? Could this capacity create greater mission value somewhere else?

    Those questions do not automatically tell us what to stop, nor should they. Decisions involving programs, employees, client expectations, and institutional commitments require judgment. But good questions create clarity, and I continue to believe that clarity precedes progress.

    Time, people, leadership attention, and organizational focus are finite assets. The leadership question is simple: What is consuming capacity without producing enough mission value? Recognizing the cost of clutter is the first step. Next week, we move to the harder question: What should we stop doing?

    —-

    At Aman and Associates, I work with governing boards, CEOs, and executive teams to strengthen organizational focus and align resources with mission and impact. Through board retreats, CEO mentoring, strategic conversations, and a focused two-hour Zoom Futuring session, I help leaders identify where organizational capacity is being consumed and whether those commitments still produce sufficient mission value. The goal is not simply to do less, but to create the time, talent, funding, and leadership attention needed for what matters most. Capacity is a strategic asset, and protecting it is one of the most important forms of stewardship a leadership team can provide.

    Rick Aman, PhD, Aman & Associates – rick@rickaman.com | rickaman.com 

     

     

  • Less but Better – Good Does Not Always Mean Right

    Less but Better – Good Does Not Always Mean Right

    When Good Programs No Longer Serve the Mission

    One of the hardest leadership lessons is learning that a good program can still be the wrong program for the future.

    In nonprofit organizations and higher education, programs often begin for sound reasons. A community need is identified. Funding becomes available. A team leader sees an opportunity. A board supports an idea that clearly aligns with the mission at the time. The program is funded and begins, people align with it, and over time it becomes part of the organization’s identity.

    The difficulty comes later.

    Needs change. Workforce demand evolves. Technology alters how services can be delivered. Funding models move in new directions. What once represented innovation can eventually become routine, and what once served the mission exceptionally well may no longer be the best use of organizational capacity. That does not mean the original decision was wrong. It simply means things change.

    This is an important distinction for boards, CEOs, and executive teams. Leaders sometimes hesitate to revisit long-standing programs because they fear doing so somehow diminishes the people who created them or the students and communities they served. I have seen this happen many times. A program may have decades of history, strong advocates, and meaningful accomplishments, and yet the strategic question still needs to be asked: does this program continue to deserve the same investment today?

    Last week, I introduced this series with the idea that organizational focus sometimes requires the courage to stop. This week, I want to go one step deeper. The real challenge is not deciding whether something is good. The challenge is deciding whether it remains right.

    Mission Must Be More Than a Shield for the Status Quo

    Organizations often invoke mission when defending existing programs. We say, “This is part of who we are,” or “We have always served this population,” or “This program reflects our values.” Those statements may be true, but they do not automatically answer the strategic question. Mission should guide decisions, but it should not become a shield that protects every legacy activity from examination.

    During my years as a president, I learned that nearly every program could make some legitimate connection to the mission. That was not enough. If everything can be justified by the mission, then the mission stops being useful as a decision-making tool. The better question is whether a program is one of the strongest ways to advance the mission today. That requires leaders to separate mission from habit. It also requires us to distinguish between honoring history and being governed by it. Organizations should respect the work that brought them to the present, but they cannot assume that yesterday’s structure will automatically serve tomorrow’s needs.

    This is particularly difficult when internal ownership is strong. Staff, faculty, donors, or community partners may feel deeply connected to a particular program. That commitment deserves respect, but sentiment cannot be the only criterion for continuation. Mission alignment should be demonstrated through outcomes, relevance, and impact. Are students succeeding? Are clients being served effectively? Is the program producing results that justify the resources required? Could those same resources create greater mission impact somewhere else? Those questions are not hostile to mission. They are expressions of stewardship.

    Relevance vs Legacy

    I believe boards and CEOs need a disciplined way to distinguish relevance from legacy. Legacy has value. It tells us where we came from. It gives organizations identity and continuity. Some programs become part of the institutional story and help define reputation. But legacy alone is not a strategy.

    Relevance asks a different set of questions. Does this activity still solve an important problem? Is there evidence that the people we serve value it? Does it still represent an area where the organization has distinctive strength?

    I have seen organizations continue programs with very low participation because “we have always offered them.” I have also seen institutions maintain processes that were once necessary but had become redundant because technology or regulation changed. In each case, the obstacle was rarely a lack of information. More often, it was a reluctance to challenge history.

    That is where governance matters. Boards should not manage programs, but they should expect leadership to demonstrate how major programs and initiatives contribute to mission and long-term sustainability. CEOs, in turn, should create an environment where executive teams can raise difficult questions without being accused of disloyalty to the organization’s past. A healthy leadership culture makes it possible to say, “This has served us well, but we need to examine whether it still belongs in our future.” That sentence respects the past without surrendering the future to it.

    Disciplined Way to Ask the Question

    The guiding question for this week is simple: If we were starting today, would we create this again? I like this question because it temporarily removes the weight of history. It asks leaders to imagine that the program does not yet exist and then evaluate it based on today’s mission, needs, resources, and opportunities.

    If the answer is yes, that is useful. It confirms that the program remains central to the mission and may warrant continued investment. If the answer is no, that does not necessarily mean the program should be eliminated. Instead, it signals the need for leadership to understand why. The program may need to be redesigned. A partnership may accomplish the same objectives more effectively. Or, after careful consideration, leadership may conclude that the program has served its purpose and it is time to stop.

    I would pair the guiding question with several related considerations in leadership discussions. If we created this today, what problem would we say it solves? Who would we design it to serve? What outcomes would we expect? And how would we know whether it was successful? Those questions shift the discussion away from defending the current structure and toward evaluating purpose. The exercise can be especially powerful during board retreats or strategic planning sessions because it gives people permission to challenge assumptions without immediately advocating elimination. The goal is not to produce a list of cuts. The goal is to create clarity.

    Honoring the Past Without Being Trapped by It

    Strong organizations know how to honor what came before while still making room for what needs to come next. I think this is where leadership maturity becomes especially important. It is relatively easy to celebrate something new. It is much harder to thoughtfully conclude that something valuable has completed its useful life.

    When that decision is necessary, leaders should communicate it with respect. We should acknowledge what the program accomplished, the people who built it, and the lives it affected. Ending or changing something should not erase its contribution. But respect for the past should not require permanent continuation.

    The discipline of organizational focus requires leaders to make choices based on mission, impact, and future relevance. That may mean continuing some programs with renewed investment. It may mean redesigning others. And yes, occasionally it may mean bringing something to a thoughtful end. The goal is not less for the sake of less. The goal is less, but better.

    Boards and CEOs have a responsibility to ensure that organizational resources are concentrated where they can create the greatest value. That responsibility becomes even more important in periods of limited funding, growing expectations, and rapid change. So, I would encourage leadership teams to take one significant program or initiative and ask the question without defensiveness: If we were starting today, would we create this again? Then listen carefully to the answer.

    Next week, I will continue the series with The Cost of Organizational Clutter and examine what happens when too many priorities, programs, and initiatives begin competing for the same limited organizational capacity.

    —-

    At Aman and Associates, I work with governing boards, CEOs, and executive teams to strengthen organizational focus and align resources with mission and impact. Through board retreats, CEO mentoring, strategic conversations, and a focused two-hour Zoom Futuring session, I help leaders step beyond traditional planning to define their preferred future and examine what should continue, what should change, and what may have completed its useful life. Clarity about what belongs in the future—and what does not—is one of the most important forms of stewardship a leadership team can provide.

     Rick Aman, PhD, Aman & Associates – rick@rickaman.com | rickaman.com 

    —–

  • Less, but Better – The Discipline of Organizational Focus

    Less, but Better – The Discipline of Organizational Focus

    The Courage to Stop

    Opening the Series: Why Less May Be Better

    “Perfection is achieved, not when there is nothing more to add, but when there is nothing left to take away.” — Antoine de Saint-Exupéry

    Leadership has a natural bias toward addition. We launch new programs, create new initiatives, establish goals, and develop new measures. Much of this work begins for good reasons. A need emerges, an opportunity presents itself, funding becomes available, or someone has an idea worth pursuing. We respond because leaders are expected to move organizations forward. “Don’t just stand there, do something….” What we are much less comfortable doing is stopping.

    During my years as a community college president, I rarely encountered a shortage of good ideas. The more difficult challenge was determining which ideas deserved our limited time, money, talent, and attention. Every organization eventually discovers that there are more worthwhile things it could do than it has the capacity to do well.

    Organizations also tend to accumulate activities much more easily than they shed them. A program begins because a community need existed ten years ago. A committee is created to solve a particular problem. A report is developed because someone once needed the information. A meeting gets placed on the calendar and gradually becomes permanent. Over time, each becomes part of the organizational landscape and culture. People may no longer remember why something began, but they know that it has always been there.

    That is the premise of this new five-week series, Less, but Better: The Discipline of Organizational Focus. I want to explore a simple, but sometimes uncomfortable proposition: perhaps stronger organizations are not always those doing more. Perhaps they are the organizations that are clearest about what matters most and disciplined enough to stop doing what no longer deserves their capacity.

    This is not an argument for indiscriminate cost cutting or abandoning programs simply because they are difficult or expensive. It is about organizational focus. Over the next several weeks, I will explore when good programs may no longer serve the mission, the hidden cost of organizational clutter, how leaders can determine what should stop, and how the capacity created through subtraction can be reinvested in what matters most. That journey begins with the courage to stop.

    The Leadership Challenge of Stopping

    Starting something carries energy. There may be a ribbon cutting, an announcement, a new initiative, or at least a sense of momentum. Ending something feels very different, Programs develop constituencies, processes develop owners, committees develop members, and traditions become embedded in the budget. After enough time, the question can subtly shift from, “Why are we doing this?” to, “How could we possibly stop doing this?” That is where organizational inertia begins.

    One of the lessons I learned as a president is that past success does not automatically justify future investment. Something can have been exactly the right decision ten years ago and still be the wrong investment today. Recognizing that reality does not diminish the people who created it or the value it once produced. Circumstances change. Students change. Communities change. Technology changes. Workforce needs change. Organizations themselves change, and leadership requires us to periodically ask whether our commitments still serve the organization we are becoming. There is an old saying: “If you don’t like change, you’re going to like obsolescence even less.” The challenge for leaders is not simply deciding what new things to begin. It is also having the courage to recognize when something that once mattered has run its course and then choosing to stop.

    Sometimes we need to reframe that assumption. The decision to stop something does not necessarily mean it failed. Sometimes it succeeded and its purpose was fulfilled. Sometimes another approach now accomplishes the same outcome more effectively. Sometimes the need has changed. And sometimes, if we are willing to admit it, something simply no longer produces enough value to justify the resources devoted to it. That leads to an important leadership question: What are we continuing primarily because we have always done it? The answer may reveal more about organizational strategy than another twenty pages of a strategic plan.

    Strategic Subtraction Is Stewardship

    Every organization operates with finite resources. Budgets are finite, employee energy is finite, leadership attention is finite, and time may be the most limited resource of all. When we say yes to one activity, we are implicitly saying no to something else. That is why I view strategic subtraction as a form of stewardship.

    Clutter has a cost. People become busy without always being productive. Leaders move rapidly from meeting to meeting. Strategic plans grow longer. Priorities multiply. Employees hear that everything is important, which eventually means that nothing is truly prioritized. The purpose of stopping, therefore, is not primarily to save money. The greater objective is to create capacity. I would encourage boards and executive teams to examine activities through three lenses: Does this still advance our mission? Can we demonstrate meaningful impact from the resources invested? And what other opportunity might become possible if some of those resources were redirected? These questions change the conversation. Instead of asking whether an activity is good or bad, leaders ask whether it remains among the best uses of organizational capacity.

    Using “WHO” prompt + AI to Challenge Our Assumptions

    Artificial intelligence gives leaders another way to engage this conversation. I am not suggesting that AI should decide which programs should continue or which activities should stop. Those decisions require human judgment, organizational knowledge, governance, and an understanding of the people affected. But AI can be useful for something leaders sometimes struggle to do: challenge assumptions.

    I have been using a simple prompting approach I call WHO. The purpose is to make our interaction with AI more intentional.

    The W asks, WHO is the AI? We begin by giving AI a role appropriate to the problem. For this conversation, I might say, “Act as an experienced nonprofit strategist who is willing to challenge legacy practices rather than simply affirm them.”

    The H means, HELP AI with instruction and context. AI cannot understand an organization simply because we provide the name of a college or nonprofit. We need to explain the mission, strategic priorities, programs, outcomes, costs, staffing, community expectations, and whatever other information would help AI understand the situation or context.

    The O defines WHAT outcome do we want? Rather than asking AI, “What should we cut?” I might ask it to identify activities that warrant deeper leadership examination based on mission alignment, measurable impact, resource consumption, duplication, or opportunity cost, and then identify what evidence leadership should review before reaching a conclusion.

    That difference matters. AI is most valuable here not as the decision-maker, but as a second set of eyes. It can identify patterns or themes, challenge assumptions, compare alternatives, and ask questions that may not naturally emerge around the leadership table. A leadership team might provide AI with a list of recurring programs, meetings, reports, committees, and strategic initiatives and ask where duplication may exist. It could also ask AI to argue the opposite position and explain why those same activities might need to continue. I always like to assign a number to the What. “Provide three programs that the board might consider for review.”

    The goal is not to outsource leadership. The goal is to improve the quality of the questions leadership considers. One way I do this is to ask AI, before it responds to my prompt, to ask me three questions that would help it better understand my intent. Those questions often expose missing context, unclear assumptions, or gaps in my thinking. By giving AI greater clarity and context before it responds, I usually get a much more useful result.

    Closing: Courage Creates Capacity

    Organizational focus requires more than deciding what to pursue. It also requires the courage to decide what no longer deserves our time, attention, and resources. Programs, meetings, processes, and initiatives may once have served an important purpose, but preserving yesterday’s commitments can limit tomorrow’s opportunities. The strongest organizations understand their purpose clearly enough to make choices and protect their capacity for what matters most.

    As this series begins, I would encourage every board and executive team to ask one question: If we were not already doing this, would we choose to start it today?

    The answer may be uncomfortable, but it may also reveal capacity that has been hiding in plain sight. Next week, I will take that question one step further in When Good Programs No Longer Serve the Mission.

    —–

    At Aman and Associates, I work with governing boards, CEOs, and executive teams to create greater clarity around purpose, priorities, and organizational direction. Through board retreats, CEO mentoring, and facilitated strategic conversations, I help organizations identify what matters most and create the focus needed to act on it. Sometimes the path toward stronger performance begins not by adding another initiative, but by having the courage to ask what we can stop.

    Rick Aman, PhD, Aman & Associates – rick@rickaman.com | rickaman.com 

  • Seminar – Shaping Tomorrow, Today

    Seminar – Shaping Tomorrow, Today

    An Invitation to Create Your Organization’s Preferred Future Seminar

    Over the past three weeks, I have been writing about Futuring—an idea that has shaped much of my thinking about leadership, strategy, and organizational change. I began with the experience of walking into the new Future Tech Building at the College of Eastern Idaho and realizing that I was standing inside something that, years earlier, had existed only as an idea. From there, I explored how leaders can move from imagining a Preferred Future to creating one, and why choosing a future worth pursuing is ultimately a leadership responsibility.

    Those articles generated several conversations about a natural next question: How do you actually put Futuring into practice? On Friday, October 2, I will spend a full day exploring that question through Boise State University’s PACE program in a seminar titled Shaping Tomorrow, Today: A Futuring Masterclass for Visionary Leaders. If the ideas I have been writing about have interested you, I would enjoy having you join me.

    Begin with the Future, Not the Plan

    Futuring begins with a somewhat different way of thinking about strategic planning. Traditional planning often begins with the organization we have today. We examine our mission and values, assess strengths and weaknesses, identify problems, establish goals, and begin moving forward. All of that can be useful, but there is a danger in allowing today’s organization to establish the boundaries of what we can imagine for tomorrow.

    Futuring begins farther out. It asks leaders to look three to five years into the future and consider a different question: What organization do we want to become? Once that destination becomes clear, we can work backward to determine what we should begin doing today. Futuring does not replace strategic planning; it changes where the planning begins.

    An important part of that process is recognizing that there is never just one future. The Possible Future asks what could happen as technology, demographics, economics, competition, public expectations, and other forces change. The Probable Future asks where our current direction is likely to take us if we continue largely as we are.

    But the central question of Futuring comes with the Preferred Future: Of all the futures that might emerge, what future do we intentionally want to help create? That moves leaders from forecasting what might happen toward considering what they want to make possible. We cannot control the future, but neither are we simply passengers waiting for it to arrive.

    Centering Purpose: Ikigai for Organizations

    Before we can meaningfully answer that question, we need to understand why the organization matters in the first place. One of the frameworks we will use during the October seminar is Ikigai for Organizations, my adaptation of the Japanese concept often associated with purpose and meaning.

    For organizations, I center the conversation around four questions: What do we love? What are we good at? What does our community need? What will sustain the organization? The intersection of those questions can help leaders rediscover the purpose at the center of their organization.

    I think of this as Centering Purpose. Futuring should not simply produce a bigger or busier organization; it should create one increasingly aligned with why it exists and the difference it is uniquely positioned to make. From there, three simple words become particularly useful: Why, What, and How. Purpose establishes why the organization exists, the Preferred Future describes what it intends to become, and strategy determines how we begin moving toward that destination.

    The sequence matters. Leaders naturally want to move quickly to the how—initiatives, budgets, timelines, assignments, and measures. But an organization can be extraordinarily busy without necessarily making meaningful progress. I frequently return to a simple principle in my work with leadership teams: clarity precedes progress. Without clarity about why the organization matters and what future we are trying to create, more activity may simply move us somewhere faster.

    AI Gives Leaders a New Futuring Tool

    There is another dimension of Futuring that makes this an especially interesting time for leaders: artificial intelligence. Organizations now have access to tools that can dramatically expand their ability to understand the forces changing around them. AI can inform the Futuring process, but organizational purpose—why we exist, what we value, and what future is worth pursuing—remains a human responsibility.

    During our day together, we will use AI not to replace leadership judgment, but to strengthen it. AI can help examine demographic and economic trends, develop and challenge a SWOT analysis, conduct a PESTEL environmental scan, identify emerging technologies and disruptions, compare peer organizations, explore scenarios, and test assumptions. Research that once required days can increasingly be explored in minutes, allowing leadership teams to ask more questions and consider more possibilities.

    As we work with AI, we will also discuss the AIM framework for prompting: Act As, Information, and Mission—a useful way to give AI the role, context, and task it needs. Better prompt construction can lead to better questions, deeper analysis, and more useful insights.

    But there is an important boundary. AI can expand what leaders see, but it cannot decide what leaders should value. It can identify trends, challenge assumptions, and help us imagine different futures. Deciding which future is worth pursuing remains a human responsibility grounded in purpose, values, judgment, wisdom, and leadership.

    Futuring Is Ultimately About Leadership

    The more I work with Futuring, the less I think of it simply as another planning methodology. It is fundamentally about leadership.

    Leaders live under the gravitational pull of the present. There is always a budget issue, staffing problem, operational challenge, new regulation, customer concern, board agenda, or unexpected event requiring attention. Responsible leaders cannot ignore those realities. But if every leadership conversation begins and ends with today’s problems, the present eventually becomes the architect of the future.

    Leadership requires managing the organization we have today while also accepting responsibility for the organization that will exist three to five years from now. A Preferred Future gives leaders another vantage point from which to make those decisions. Instead of asking only what problem needs to be solved today, we can also ask: Does this decision move us toward our Preferred Future?

    That question becomes particularly powerful when circumstances change, because they inevitably will. Futuring does not provide a detailed map of the next five years, nor should it. Technology will change, new opportunities will emerge, and strategies will need to adapt. A Preferred Future provides a destination that gives those changing strategies direction—and over time, that can become a leadership discipline.

    Join Me on Friday, October 2, 2026

    If you serve on a governing board, lead a business or nonprofit, work in government or education, or have responsibility for helping an organization navigate what comes next, I invite you to bring that organization with you conceptually. Bring the challenges you are facing, the assumptions you have about where the organization is headed, and the questions that may not yet have good answers. Most importantly, bring a willingness to look beyond the organization as it exists today and imagine what it could become. This will not be a day of abstract discussion about the future, but an opportunity to begin doing the work of shaping one.

    Shaping Tomorrow, Today: A Futuring Masterclass for Visionary Leaders will be held Friday, October 2, from 9:00 a.m. to 4:00 p.m. at Boise State University’s Yanke Family Research Park in Boise. The registration fee is $275. I would enjoy having some of my LinkedIn friends and colleagues join me for the day as we move from talking about the future to doing the work of intentionally shaping it.

    Learn more and register through Boise State University PACE

    Every future begins as an idea. Its real power comes when people see that future together and begin moving toward it. Perhaps that is the question worth leaving with leaders and governing boards: Are you planning from where your organization is today, or are you creating a clear enough picture of the future that people can begin moving toward it together?

    Rick Aman, PhD | Aman & Associates – Strategic Futuring & Board Training
    rick@rickaman.com | rickaman.com

    The future will arrive. The leadership opportunity is to decide how intentionally we will help shape it.